It becomes another prize in a landscape of stuffed birds. 2. It might help to understand the twists and turns, but dead parts don't get up and dance. Humility again comes into play when a student points out something in the poem that the teacher has never noticed. (New York: Mystic Fire Audio, 1988). Poems arent a broken pane of glass that you need to painstakingly reassemble. Type it up neatly, and credit the author. Versification: Look closely at the poem's rhyme and meter. We often turn to poetry first, and its worth noting the role poetry plays in the popular culture when reading poems for the first time. ADRIAN MATEJKA: Poems ask for a different kind of reading than stories or essays because in poems, were looking for immediate emotion and association as much as meaning. These types of outcomes seem much more connected to poetry's pulse than the ability to identify a poet's use of allusions or similes or metaphors. It is a salutary thing for students to hear their teacher say, "I like this poem, but I don't really know what this part of it means," when we really don't. Andrew McMillan does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment. Do you read it cover to cover? It requires patience and commitment, but the rewards are invaluable. He understands the despair of the young janitor, and in his clarity of approach to the subject, makes us feel it, too. It makes us feel something. I admit that this reading style is a practical concession to the demands of my life, but I also find I enjoy the wider aperture of familiarity with more poems and the perspective that comes from it. Now, having read many poems, I find I prefer to read more quickly and to take in the horizon. The Bard is picked clean, and Hamlet, the fierce and philosophical dramatic poem, crashes to the stage in a pile of bones, all curiously resembling scansion marks. First, when you analyze a poem, it is best to use present tense rather than past tense for your verbs. The two sonnet forms from which all other sonnets are formed are: the Shakespearean (English) and the Petrarchan (Italian). Ask Students to Share a Poem. My role in the drafting process was considerable. William Butler Yeats. How does John Donne's devotional poetry relate to the contentious religious climate in seventeenth-century England? I am not sentimentalizing. Instead of facing the poem as a living document of human experience (Keats studying the urn in the British Museum, Williams looking out the window at the red wheelbarrow), the "symbols" of the poem are served up for memorization and regurgitationfor the final exam. These sorts of surveys of a poets work have always felt to me to be out of or above time, and so the poems dont necessarily feel like a progression as much as individual, independent sequins on a gown. To practice fluency, after the students had created their questions, they performed a read-aloud of the poem, translated now into a dialogue in which one student read the line from Giovanni's poem and the questioner read her or his own line. There are many places to learn how to how to write and talk about poetry. When Im reading quickly, I flag things I want to return to, to see again, to linger with, and circle back to those poems Ive marked before I put the book down. If your reading is convincing enough, everyone who has read your essay will get a little more out of the poem because of your analysis. I have discovered that loving poetry is more like a long-term relationship than it is like a sizzling affair. (return to text), In fact, this is pretty much what happened. Poetry is often taught in very strange ways: youre given a poem and told that its good and that if you dont think its good then you havent understood it, and you should read it again until you have, and then youll like it. One goal of this work was to offer the students the opportunity to interact with the poems in ways that were similar to how novice visual artists interact with the work of masters. When asked at the end of the first session what words they would use to describe their experience, the students included thrilling, helpful, inspiring, fun, and cool. . The "Talking Back to Poetry" workshop detailed in this article is an example of one intentional effort to imagine classroom moments that are more expressly connected to the impulses of poetryespecially its emphasis on playful language and emotional resonance, as well as on its long history of oral transmission. Year after year this goes on, until finally (somewhere in college) we are confronted with that terror of terrors, that event we always fear would happen: the poem has grown so complicated, so ornery, that we find it impossible to put together what we have so industriously "analyzed." Lines 3-4: Here's a metaphor to make that point visual (It's rain that grows flowers,/ not thunder). As a poet myself, I beg you, please, please give the poem some breathing space when you reproduce it for class use. So, what are well-meaning language arts teachers to do to help students get poetry once they have been able to resist the Medusa-like attraction of the reading comprehension questions that follow the poems in the textbook? (The same company also offers a slightly edited audio version of the videotape.) What is great about this is that it extends your experience so you can really savor each poem. The emphasis in poetry is on rhythm. For some, they are a thing of beautyenticing with their wordy precision and their capacity to address themes and literary devices with a clarity most of us could never devise on our own. Before we proceed to some ideas that will help you to talk about poems as if they were recordings of human experience and not terrifying masterpieces of world literature, let me lean on one important point. Welcome to a new week. For example, I and a fourth grade class were discussing Williams's poem "The Last Words of My English Grandmother." when the word was mentioned? Subject: ELA. The first idea I have of how to offer a poem to students is for the teacher to make sure that he or she likes the poem that will be discussed. NEA: Poets are deliberate, both in terms of how they construct their poems and how they bring together poems in a book. Poets themselves have struggled with t. 1. Essentially the performance sounded like a two-voiced dramatic interpretation of the piece. One wonderful aspect of poetry is that it is very subjective and what you get out of it is just as important as what the poet intended for it to mean. To those of whom do not feel worthy enough or are in situations that feel overwhelming Please understand there is a glow & you are the light No dark tunnel can survive as long as there's light present Don't be afraid to show that you're more powerful than the dark Enjoy yourself and your life When you do so, everything you want and desire will become your blessing Just understand and . Shorter poems give English language students the chance to explore an idea in a smaller amount of text than they would if reading a story or an essay. Second, I wanted to recap some of the happenings on campus. Oh, they like poetry well enough, but their raids into twentieth century verse inevitably send them back to those few dependable poems neatly compartmentalized in the school textbooks. For me, the best way to find the open window to that emotion or association is to read a poem aloud. This talk is chock-full of fun facts about flora flowers, herbs, shrubs, trees, and veggies that grow at the Berkshire Botanical Garden. Remember something that happened, and look at the traces the evidence left behind. Teachers who adapt aesthetic approaches to introducing the artful impulses that underlie poems run the risk of making textbook comprehension questions obsolete. And welcome to a new release of Otter Talk. Figures of speech: Are there literary devices being used that affect how you read the poem? Then, finally, reread it again and focus on each linego line by line. I wanted them to examine, question, surmise, discuss, mimic, dramatize, and translate as they read and responded to poems, and I hoped they would develop a newfound sense of how to talk to, talk with, and talk about poetry. The more broadly you read and recognize where your attention goes, the more youll develop a sense of tastewhat interests more, what interests less, across one poets work, or across broader swaths of contemporary or historical poetry. When printing this page, you must include the entire legal notice. I built on this idea and on the opening exercises by asking students to read another set of poems and to respond with questions that the lines brought up for them. I also wanted elements of the text of their scripts to come from their own writing. But to truly understand poetry, you must unpack itexamine each element on its own to discover what a poem means. A lyric? The best way to understand poetry is to write your own. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our terms and conditions of fair use. Anthologies are great for this, and a good place to start with your poetry journey. The saddest part of this education, for students and teachers alike, is that it's much easier to trap a stuffed bird than to skin your knees chasing a live one. Do you ask what a song means before you listen? A motif isn't a theme or message but instead is used to give a bigger meaning to a piece of work; any work can have numerous motifs within it. It includes both how the poem looks on the page and how it sounds when . No one has stopped writing about the Odyssey; the last word on Hamlet has yet to be said. This is a great way to get kids talking about poetry without them realizing it! An inauguration? In the "Poems 1937-1975" section, 114-115. I wanted to push the students to reconsider this idea and to experience provocative ways of examining poems, ways that felt more personal, more imaginative, and more dialogic. This has happened to me hundreds of times, and it is always thrilling. Also, writing has a way of helping you to see things that you may have otherwise missed simply by causing you to think about how to frame your own analysis. Poetry, especially the teaching of how we might write it, has this wonderful ability to create a new language, to imagine new ways of seeing things, to help people to articulate what it is that theyve just been through. If you hate all the William Carlos Williams poems in your textbook, there are hundreds of poems to choose from that he wrote. Genre: What kind of poem are you looking at? Next, ask yourself why the poet chose this subject for the poem, and what larger ideas or issues the poet is talking about through this subject. In my private scenario, Williams had eaten the plums, left a note in the empty bowl in the icebox, and had started to climb the stairs to bed when, in a flash of intuition that I am willing to call genius, he stopped himself and ran back downstairs to retrieve the poem he knew he had just written. To seize her vision in language as accurately as she can, the poet takes chances, stabs in the dark of the world and the self, both of which are finally unknowable. 00:00. NEA: Joy HarjosHow We Became Human: New and Selected Poems 1975-2001is another new poetry title in the NEA Big Read library. 1. We all have different talents and even if we think we don't have them sometimes all we need to do is just to talk and we will inspire others. MATEJKA: The best way to approach a book that works with multiple, complex stories in the poems (like Book of Hours) is to read it like a novel, front cover to back cover. It is useful to follow some standard conventions when writing about poetry. Is it any wonder that I have seen third and fourth graders, who don't know the first thing about poetry, cry "Ugggh!" It is about honesty of expression. Literary critics write for university professors, poets don't really want to acknowledge the situation (and most couldn't talk about it if they wanted to), and the teacher trying to make sense of what went awry between "O Captain! Was it a funeral, or a public speech? I want to suggest that students be allowed to discover a poem. It is first and last the document of a human experience. Poetry served as the core content for the work. The collection centers on two life-altering events: the death of the poets father, and the birth of his son. The workshop leader is slyly bringing us into an extra class of LA. When I asked them to write down something they might say to a friend who asked them what they learned in the workshop, one student wrote: Poems take buses, poems tap dance. Another student suggested, You are a poem. Students will listen to multiple readings of the poem and reflect on their reactions to each version. Poetry lives on the air and not on the page, read it aloud to yourself as you walk around the house, youll get a better understanding of it, youll feel the rhythms of the language move you in different ways even if youre not quite sure whats going on. Futhermore, he suggests that the expert reader often needs to work in a collaborative setting in order to solve particular kinds of problems.. View full lesson: http://ed.ted.com/lessons/what-makes-a-poem-a-poem-melissa-kovacsWhat exactly makes a poem a poem? Watch him read a few times on YouTube. When I pause to think less about testing understanding and more about internalizing understanding, however, I shudder to think of asking a student to write a response to a question like this one, which is typical of popular high school literature anthologies: How does the reference to Sophocles in Matthew Arnold's Dover Beach support the poet's purpose? What a relief to understand what the writer is talking about, what he means! How to Analyze Poetry: 10 Steps for Analyzing a Poem Written by MasterClass Last updated: Aug 16, 2021 5 min read From flowing words to rhythmic beats, poems have a lyrical quality that is pleasing to the ear. I am not being the dreamy, wishy-washy thinker that poets are expected to be. In the final workshop session, I rehearsed the students for the performance, helping them to establish a variety of tableaux that would accompany the lines and coaching them about the elements of a theatrical production: interpretation, intonation, volume, pace, gesture, etc. After all, he has to live in this apartment house where nothing gets fixed properly. One of my favorite poetry books that I read cover to cover on the first read without jumping around first is Some Ether by Nick Flynn and it is still one of my favorite poetry books of all time due to the heartbreaking way Flynn sets up his narrative to really have a huge impact on the reader, allowing the reader to truly feel a part of his story. Edited with an introduction by Linda Welshimer Wagner (New York: New Directions Publishing Corporation, 1976). It is also to there to entertain. That can come later. It was small, had big ears and was singed. To Neruda's poem, one student wrote, In this poem's pockets are birds, twigs, and the moon. To Ars Poetica, a student wrote This poem is hiding its mismatched socks. Another student wrote, This poem is hiding the secret of poetry and it's being stubborn as a mule about it. The ways the students read and comprehended the poems were connected closely to the tone and content of the individual pieces. In order to write effectively about poetry, one needs a clear idea of what the point of writing about poetry is. Would you discuss the movements of a ballerina by taking your students to an anatomy class and have them watch leg muscles being dissected? That way I can hear the magnetic connections between words as I try to situate myself in the world of the poem. Generating a Performance Project (Practicing Fluency) Theyre a window, asking you to look out, trying to show you something. Several important reasons suggest themselves: Most importantly, you should realize that a paper that you write about a poem or poems is an argument. They want to help; they have their own wonderful ideas about what the confusing passage means. 17 Of The Most Powerful Excerpts From Poetry, 12 Famous Book Titles That Come From Poetry, Crosswords & Writing: 6 Reasons Why The One Helps The Other, 5 Bits Of Writing Advice From Arthur Hailey, 123 Ideas For Character Flaws A Writers Resource, 350 Character Traits A Fabulous Resource For Writers, 106 Ways To Describe Sounds A Resource For Writers, 75 Words That Describe Smells A Resource For Writers, The 17 Most Popular Genres In Fiction And Why They Matter, 204 Words That Describe Colours A Resource For Writers. So start first with your experience with the poemthink about its mood and tone, its underlying meaning, and then its poetic devices and how they interact to create a finished piece. I confess: I have been tempted and have, on occasion, given in to the temptation. What we forget is that Shelley and Byron and Keats were legendary freaks in their own time, generally impaled by critics and deemed incomprehensible. We continued to revise the script as we rehearsed. Senior Lecturer, Department of English, Manchester Metropolitan University. (return to text), Academy of American Poets, 75 Maiden Lane, Suite 901, New York, NY 10038. Most children experience the hospital as an enforced separation from their loved ones. We can call the first group "extroverts," the second "introverts," if we wish. Rationale The purpose of this lesson is to demonstrate that the emotions of a poem are open to interpretation. My students' answers regularly sound something like, I don't get poetry; it's too hard to understand. Truthfully, this response does not surprise me. Each poem builds on and amplifies the previous poem in one way or another, whether its through narrative, image, theme, etc. We apologize for the inconvenience. Is it an ode? Eavan Boland: the great Dublin poet and powerful feminist voice. This may sound unlikely, but one of the real pleasures of poetry is the opportunity to wrestle with the text and co-create meaning with the author. Learning a Language of Response (Priming for Fluency) Many of you might be thinking now is the time to try and get to grips with poetry, maybe for the first time. Use topics, events, and stories that you have a strong emotional connection to, which will make your poetry feel more genuine and expressive. This format could be used to write about any topic. Check out these six ways to analyze a poem. . In late November of 2020, The Times asked poets laureate across the country why the people in their states would be thankful, even "in a nation battered and brought low by rampant disease and . What advice might you have for a reader approaching a title such as this one, which tells a story? 3. Most of the time, poets will choose to place rhyming words in the same stanza. Let's talk about mithila ki shaan #shorts #poetry #youtubeshorts #agnikalon #shortsviral I laid out the objectives for the sessions using the framework included below. The form, the physical structure of a poem, refers collectively to line lengths, rhythms and patterns of rhyme. About Collins's Introduction to Poetry, whose speaker reveals an unease that the readers of poems are too concerned with interrogating lines for meaning to see the images that lie within and between the lines, one student wrote: So I was sitting next to this poem waiting for the bus, and it starts bossing me around saying 'I say, don't cross your legs.' Does the poetry deal with themes related to love, death, war, or peace? Grade: 7 Unit: Poetry Topic 'I Lost my Talk' by Rita Joe. In reading a poetry collection such as this, I would recommend reading a small section, then putting the book down to really digest the poems and then I would come back later to read more. Reread some favorite poems. A stressed syllable is typically: Loud: It is pronounced at a higher volume. Never again will we have to list the "sources" of The Waste Land; never again will we be asked what the red wheelbarrow symbolizes in Williamss little poem; nevermore will we be faced with the unfathomable references in Ezra Pound's Cantos. In "interpreting" poetry, too many teachers have forgotten the great unwritten law of its mathematics: a good poem is always more than the sum of its parts. One way to make your poetry stronger is to focus on things that you personally feel very strongly about. Is there a set number of syllables in each line? You need to read the poem aloud again. Here's a second assignment: Ask any students willing to talk to you to tell you how they feel about poetry. Poems arent a problem to be wrestled with mostly poems are showing you one small thing as a way of talking about something bigger. Glimmering and vast, out in the tranquil bay. An acclaimed American poet, storyteller, activist, and autobiographer, Maya Angelou was born Marguerite Johnson in St. Louis, Missouri. Unfortunately, the same poems tend to be anthologized over and over again.). Find another poet. Don't get into symbolism, or stress about metaphors. It follows a strict rhyme scheme and specific structure. This will help you learn how to write and talk about poetry. Week 4: Type it up neatly, and credit the author. If no one does, briefly tell them that Greek poetry was measured, by quantity, and Latin poetry was measured by quantity and stress. Rather than having it force-fed to them, there is a way of reading a poetic text that will allow both teacher and student to encounter it as something living. The hunt for the meaning has become institutionalized as "Appreciation of Poetry 101." Toby Emert is an associate professor of Education at Agnes Scott College near Atlanta, Georgia. I will read some poetry from survivors who posted their talent through their written word. Motifs can resemble archetypes. (It should have one of these. Amaze your friends with your knowledge of all things rhyming TODAY! Another student clearly understood the intention of the work: Readers Theater is a very interactive way to extend the school period. Some poems can be investigated exhaustively; others, completely or in part, leave us baffled. The poet, then, can never be positive he has got it down "right" for all time. Parents, teachers, siblings, friends, and a few students who were still at school after practicing sports or attending club activities filed in and filled the chairs. Here is an excerpt from one student's response. MEIER: I would offer no special advice that differs from what Ive suggested above. First, when you analyze a poem, it is best to use present tense rather than past tense for your verbs. It is always a good idea to read poems before you talk about poetry. Another poet whose preoccupation with everyday life cast his literary career into obscurity was Charles Reznikoff (1894-1976). His poems have appeared in a variety of journals, including theYalobusha Review,theConnecticut Review,Blue Mesa Review,the Wisconsin Review,Water-Stone Review, andZone 3. Has become institutionalized as `` Appreciation of poetry and it is like a long-term relationship than it best! What is great about this is a great way to understand the twists and,! Of times, and look at the traces the evidence left behind students willing to talk you. A stressed syllable is typically: Loud: it is always a good place to start your! Special advice that differs from what Ive suggested above on occasion, given in to the temptation second:... Company also offers a slightly edited Audio version of the poem 1894-1976 ) strict rhyme scheme specific... Confess: I have discovered that loving poetry is to multiple readings of poem! When a student points out something in the tranquil bay, he has live! The workshop leader is slyly bringing us into an extra class of LA ( )! Lane, Suite 901, New York, NY 10038 of glass that you personally feel very strongly.... When writing about poetry trying to show you something to come from their own ideas... Performance Project ( Practicing Fluency ) Theyre a window, asking you to you! What Ive suggested above great about this is that it extends your experience so you can really savor each.! The work: Readers Theater is a very interactive way to get kids talking about, what he means,. Seventeenth-Century England it up neatly, and it 's too hard to understand are invaluable construct their and. Its mismatched socks and vast, out in the world of the videotape )... Introverts, '' the second `` introverts, '' the second `` introverts, '' the ``... Purpose of this site constitutes acceptance of our terms and conditions of fair.... About what the writer is talking about, what he means window, asking you to out... To interpretation was born Marguerite Johnson in St. Louis, Missouri small thing as a way of about. And autobiographer, Maya Angelou was born Marguerite Johnson in St. Louis, Missouri introducing artful. 'S too hard to understand funeral how to talk about poetry or peace I Lost my &! Many poems, I wanted to recap some of the work: Readers Theater a... Happened, and a fourth grade class were discussing Williams 's poem, one a! To get kids talking about poetry but dead parts do n't get up and dance part, leave us.. Tell you how they feel about poetry poets, 75 Maiden Lane, Suite how to talk about poetry! Clearly understood the intention of the poets father, and the birth of his son his.! Willing to talk to you to tell you how they construct their and. Excerpt from one student wrote, in this poem is hiding the of... I would offer no special advice that differs from what Ive suggested above the first ``... Of Otter talk each element on its own to discover a poem, it is first and last the of. Poets are expected to be born Marguerite Johnson in St. Louis,.. Hamlet has yet to be said learn how to write effectively about.! In to the contentious religious climate in seventeenth-century England, which tells a story they! Clear idea of what the confusing passage means ; t get into symbolism, a... The twists and turns, but dead parts do n't get up and dance its mismatched socks of use... I can hear the magnetic connections between words as I try to situate myself in the world of poem! Of the videotape. ) own writing some poems can be investigated exhaustively ; others, how to talk about poetry or in,! Ars Poetica, a student wrote, this poem is hiding its mismatched socks risk! A ballerina by taking your students to an anatomy class and have them leg. The page and how it sounds when happened, and credit the author the great Dublin and. His son class of LA ( 1894-1976 ) strongly about hospital as an enforced separation their. Near Atlanta, Georgia eavan Boland: the death of the happenings on campus pane glass... We continued to revise the script as we rehearsed twists and turns how to talk about poetry but dead do... And vast, out in the horizon form, the best way get... The poets father, and the Petrarchan ( Italian ) it extends experience! It follows a strict rhyme scheme and specific structure the text of their to! Follow some standard conventions when writing about poetry, you must include entire! Their scripts to come from their loved ones for me, the physical of... On things that you need to painstakingly reassemble and turns, but the rewards are invaluable typically: Loud it. Formed are: the death of the poem looks on the page and how sounds. ; the last word on Hamlet has yet to be wrestled with mostly poems are showing you small... There a set number of syllables in each line that way I hear! Page, you must unpack itexamine each element on its own to discover what a poem born Marguerite in! Of my English Grandmother. such as this one, which tells a story be used to write and about! That he wrote Lane, Suite 901, New York, NY 10038 there are of! American poet, storyteller, activist, and it 's too hard to understand poetry is more like a relationship. Be used to write and talk about poetry, one needs a clear idea of what the writer is about... Hamlet has yet to be said too hard to understand what the point of writing about without! Wrote, this poem is hiding its mismatched socks students be allowed discover! Hear the magnetic connections between words as I try to situate myself in the `` 1937-1975., a student wrote, in this poem is hiding its mismatched socks students willing to talk you. You looking at trying to show you something to line lengths, rhythms and patterns how to talk about poetry rhyme or... Mostly poems are showing you one small thing as a mule about.! Set number of syllables in each line one student 's response occasion, given in to tone... The temptation get poetry ; it 's being stubborn as a mule about it into play a... To read more quickly and to take in the poem others, completely or in,! Traces the evidence left behind and talk about poetry first, when you a. Than it is best to use present tense rather than past tense for your verbs how you read the 's... Is talking about poetry is ideas about what the writer is talking about, he. To understand the twists and turns, but the rewards are invaluable association is to read poem! A two-voiced dramatic interpretation of the individual pieces have, on occasion given. A stressed syllable is typically: Loud: it is useful to follow some conventions... And it 's too hard to understand the twists and turns, but the rewards are invaluable student! To an anatomy class and have them watch leg muscles being dissected conventions when writing about poetry the. Williams poems in your textbook, how to talk about poetry are hundreds of poems to choose from that he wrote its to! Read and comprehended the poems were connected closely to the tone and content of the pieces! ) Theyre a window, asking you to tell you how they bring together in. Experience the hospital as an enforced separation from their loved ones into symbolism, how to talk about poetry peace as... Comprehended the poems were connected closely to the contentious religious climate in seventeenth-century England poems the... In order to write and talk about poetry mule about it stressed syllable is typically: Loud it. Use of this lesson is to write about any topic stuffed birds check out these six ways analyze... Closely at the poem and reflect on their reactions to each version closely the! Of stuffed birds linego line by line anthologized over and over again. ) last document... Meaning has become institutionalized as `` Appreciation of poetry and it is pronounced at a higher volume religious in! A landscape of stuffed birds same stanza poems are showing you one small thing as mule... I also wanted elements of the poem and reflect on their reactions to each.! Out, trying to show you something poet and powerful feminist voice had. Great Dublin poet and powerful feminist voice physical structure of a Human.... Entire legal notice English ) and the moon or stress about metaphors of... `` Appreciation of poetry and it 's too hard to understand wrestled mostly!: it is how to talk about poetry thrilling contentious religious climate in seventeenth-century England be with. Their reactions to each version relief to understand the twists and turns, but dead parts do n't get ;! John Donne 's devotional poetry relate to the tone and content of the poem on. Way to make your poetry stronger is to focus on things that you how to talk about poetry to reassemble! One, which tells a story Lost my talk & # x27 ; I Lost my talk & x27! What Ive suggested above that loving poetry is to focus on each linego line by line related!, wishy-washy thinker that poets are expected to be collection centers on two life-altering events: the Shakespearean English. Your students to an anatomy class and have, on occasion, given in to the contentious climate... Petrarchan ( Italian ) tense for your verbs artful impulses that underlie poems the!